No 5 Bombing & Gunnery School
Course 27 – Air Observer
I would like to provide a special thanks to Liz O’Brien for providing some of the information on this page and providing the web location of the course photo. Thank you Liz.

Source: Peter Kendzior personal collection – Via the RNZAF Museum Photograph Collection.
Left to right:
Back; ADL Dumont, A Tiinnosni (RCAF), RJ Parish, ME Carncross, AH Bradley, HFB Smith, A Willis, DH Palmer, HS McCullum, RE Herbert, NP Saul, JCH Sullivan, BJ Hannah.
Middle; MA Elliott, RH Dunkley, WH Lip-Guey, CR Davidson, PG Nelson, HR Powley, KW Morrison, RM Sparrow, OE Amos, CN Richards, KE Smith, EA Davis, JS Williams, RW Morton.
Front; RC Spittal, AJ McDonogh (RCAF), BS Sinclair, KS Spencer, GH Dunn, ES Roberts, E Garnett (?)(RAF), Wing Commander HY Humphries (RCAF), Wing Commander RA Dehaye (RCAF), Flight Lieutenant CR Low (RCAF), NL Burton, LV Rosser, NA Gardiner, G Nimmo, JA Logan, II Friend, MH Elliott.
Students Arrived:
Start Date:
Grad Dinner:
Graduation Parade: 24 October 1941
Graduation Date:
Nominal Role
Names below were sourced from the photo above and a search for name and initials on the Commonwealth War Graves Commission website. I will attempt some further verification with service files from the RNZAF.
- ADL Dumont,
- A Tiinnosni (RCAF),
- RJ Parish,
- Murray Ellis Carncross
- Killed in Action – 29 July 1942
- RNZAF
- Posted from Course 27-Air Observer, No 7 Air Observer School, Portage la Prairie, Manitoba, Canada of 15 September 1941
- Posted to Course 27-Air Observer, No 1 Air Navigation School, Rivers, Manitoba, Canada on 27 October 1941
- Final Rank – Pilot Officer
- Service file in the Collection of the Site Owner.
- AH Bradley,
- Harry Francis Burton Smith
- Killed in Action – 24 September 1942
- Final Rank – Flying Officer
- A Willis,
- Douglas “Doug” Haig Palmer
- Survived the war, passed away 1989.
- Highest Rank – Squadron Leader
- Awarded a Mentioned in Dispatches
- Herbert Stanley McCullum,
- Awarded Distinguished Flying Cross
- Appears that he possibly survived the war, possibly dying in 1990
- Ronald Ernest Herbert,
- Killed in Flying Accident – 25 May 1942
- Final Rank – Sergeant
- Norman Priestly Saul
- Killed in Action – 7 September 1942
- Final Rank – Sergeant
- JCH Sullivan
- Bernard John Ewart Hannah
- Killed in Action – 9 October 1943
- Final Rank – Flying Officer
- MA Elliott
- RH Dunkley
- William Herbert H Lip-Guey
- Killed in Action – 11 November 1942
- Final Rank – Sergeant
- CR Davidson
- Patrick George Nelson
- Killed in Flying Accident – 10 November 1942
- Final Rank – Sergeant
- HR Powley,
- Keith Williamson Morrison
- Killed in Action – 21 July 1943
- Final Rank – Flight Sergeant
- RM Sparrow,
- Orison Edwin Amos
- Killed in Action – 3 March 1943
- Final Rank – Flight Sergeant
- CN Richards,
- Kenneth Ewen Smith
- Killed in Action – 27 December 1942
- Final Rank – Sergeant
- EA Davis,
- John Syddall Williams
- Killed in Action – 25 May 1942
- Final Rank – Sergeant
- Robin William Morton
- Killed in Action – 3 July 1942
- Final Rank – Pilot Officer
- RC Spittal,
- AJ McDonogh (RCAF),
- BS Sinclair,
- Kenneth Stuart Spencer,
- Killed in Action – 29 July 1942
- Final Rank – Sergeant
- GH Dunn,
- ES Roberts,
- E Garnett (?)(RAF),
- Norman Lee Burton
- Missing in Action – 2 October 1943
- Final Rank – Flying Officer
- LV Rosser,
- Noble Andrew Gardiner
- Killed in Action – 28 July 1943
- Final Rank – Flying Officer
- G Nimmo,
- James Allan Logan
- Killed in Flying Accident – 10 November 1942
- Final Rank – Flying Officer
- Ian Ignatius Friend
- Killed in Action – 9 November 1942
- Final Rank – Sergeant
- Max Hilton Elliott.
- Killed in Action – 30 September 1942
- Final Rank – Sergeant
Course Strength
| No of Personnel | |
|---|---|
| Original Intake | |
| Transferred from previous course | |
| Transferred to subsequent course | |
| Wastage | |
| Killed in Flying accident | |
| Total graduates | 39 |
Commissions
| No of Personnel | |
|---|---|
| Total |
Postings
| No of Personnel | |
|---|---|
| No 1 Air Navigation School Rivers, Manitoba | 39 |
| Wastage | |
| Total |
Notes
- Wings were presented by The School Commanding Officer, Wing Commander R.A. Delhaye, D.F.C.
- Course Graduates were members of the following Air Force’s:
- 37 New Zealanders
- 2 Canadians
- Wastage remustered to:

Hi Nathan. Thank you so much for this section of RCAF.info. New Zealanders made a smaller contribution to WW2 due to population numbers, but no less significant than other nations. It’s great to see these men honoured here with their history available for others to find if they so wish. Thank you.
Thi is an update to Liz’s excellent list
ADL Dumont,
A Tiinnosni (RCAF),
RJ Parish, RNZAF killed in action 26 Jun 1942 11OTU Bremen NZ41546 Richard
John Parish
o Mar 42 – 11 OTU, Course 47, Plts & Obs
Murray Ellis Carncross NZ411718
o Killed in Action – 29 July 1942
o RNZAF
o Posted from Course 27-Air Observer, No 7 Air Observer School, Portage la
Prairie, Manitoba, Canada of 15 September 1941
o Posted to Course 27-Air Observer, No 1 Air Navigation School, Rivers,
Manitoba, Canada on 27 October 1941
o 24 Nov 41 – Plt Off from Sgt
o 4 Mar 42 – 11OTU Bassingbourn, UK
o 7 Jul 42 – 75 Sqn
o Final Rank – Pilot Officer
o Service file in the Collection of the Site Owner.
AH Bradley, RNZAF NZ402435 Arthur Hilary Bradley
o 16 Sep 42 – 214 Sqn from 1651CU
o 25 May 43 – Plt Off from Flt Sgt (as NAV)
o 17 Jun 43 – 620 Sqn from 214 Sqn
o 13 Aug 43 – DFM
o 30 Aug 43 – 1651 CU (as NAV) from 620 Sqn
o 25 Nov 43 – Fg Off from Plt Off
o 23 Aug 45 – Flt Lt (temp) from Flt (acting)
o 23 Aug 45 – Reserve of Air Force Officers
Harry Francis Burton Smith RNZAF 41641
o Killed in Action – 24 September 1942
o Spr/Sum 42 – 11 OTU – 48 Course
o Final Rank – Flying Officer
o 24 Nov 41 – Plt Off from Sgt
o 1 Oct 42 – Fg Off from Plt Off
o
https://media.api.aucklandmuseum.com/id/media/v/1030487?rendering=original.jpg
A Willis – RNZAF404437 Arthur Willis
o Jan 42 – Mar 44 – 226 Sqn (8 – 15 Sep 43 – 98 Sqn)
o 14 Jan 43 – Plt Off from Sgt
o 14 Jan 45 – Flt Lt from Fg Off
o B. 20 May 16, d. 26 Oct 79
Douglas “Doug” Haig Palmer – RNZAF41545
o Survived the war, passed away 1989.
o Highest Rank – Squadron Leader
o Awarded a Mentioned in Dispatches
o https://www.belsen.co.uk/squadron-leader-douglas-haig-palmer-rnzaf/
Herbert Stanley McCullum, RNZAF 41545
o 6 Jan 43 – 18 Sqn – last op 13 May 44
o 7 Jul 44 – Awarded Distinguished Flying Cross as WO on 18 Sqn
o Appears that he possibly survived the war, possibly dying in 1990 8 Feb 1990
Ronald Ernest Herbert – RNZAF411721
o 3 Mar 42 – 11 OTU
o 16 Apr 42 – 22 OTU
o Killed in Flying Accident – 25 May 1942 on 22 OTU
o Final Rank – Sergeant
Norman Priestly Saul – RNZAF411730
o Killed in Action – 7 September 1942 on 75 Sqn
o Final Rank – Sergeant
JCH Sullivan
o Jun – 24 Oct 42 75 Sqn
Bernard John Ewart Hannah – RNZAF403446
o 24 Nov 41 – Plt Off from Sgt
o 10 Oct 42 – Fg Off from Plt Off
o Killed in Action – 9 October 1943
o Final Rank – Flying Officer
MA Elliott – RNZAF4111720 Max Hilton Elliott
o 3 Mar 43 – 11 OTU
o 16 Jul 42 – 149 Sqn
o Killed in action 30 Sep 1942
RH Dunkley RNZAF 404344 Raymond Harold Dunckley
o Killed in Action – 27 August 1942
o Mar 42 – 11 OTU, Course 47, Plts & Obs
o Jun/Jul 42 – 1651 CU
o 6 Jul 42 – 215 Sqn
o 24 Nov 41 Plt Off from Sgt
o Final Rank – Pilot Officer
William Herbert H Lip-Guey NZ411723
o Killed in Action – 11 November 1942 608 Sqn
o Final Rank – Sergeant
CR Davidson RNZAF 411207 Colin Radcliffe Davidson
o 27 Apr 42 – 608 Sqn from 6OTU
o 22 Aug 42 – RAF Sumburgh N/E sick
o 2 May 80 – d. Manuka, NZ
Patrick George Nelson – RNZAF411726
o Killed in Flying Accident – 10 November 1942 – 53 Sqn
o Final Rank – Sergeant
HR Powley – RNZAF 411727 Herman Robert Powley
o 24 Nov 41 – Plt Off from Sgt
o 15 May 43 – commission terminated from Fg Off
Keith Williamson Morrison – RNZAF404396
o Killed in Action – 21 July 1943
o Final Rank – Flight Sergeant
RM Sparrow – RNZAF 411733 Richard Maxwell Sparrow
o 24 Nov 41 – Plt Off from Sgt – Observer
o 10 Oct 42 – Fg Off from Plt Off
o 24 Nov 43 – Flt Lt from Fg Off
o 8 Jul 42 – 57 Sqn from 11OTU 48 Course
o 29 Aug 42 – Missing – POW with rest of crew
o 2015 – d.
Orison Edwin Amos – RNZAF411717
o Killed in Action – 3 March 1943 – 15 Sqn
o Final Rank – Flight Sergeant
CN Richards – RNZAF 404846 Charles Napier Richards
o 9 Sep 43 – Plt Off from Sgt
o 9 Sep 44 Fg Off from Plt Off
o 9 Sep 15 – b.
o 2004 – d.
Kenneth Ewen Smith – RNZAF404417
o Killed in Action – 27 December 1942
o Final Rank – Sergeant
EA Davis – RNZAF 411719 Archibald England Davis
o 24 Nov 41 – Plt Off from Sgt – Observer
o 8 Jul 42 – 214 Sqn from 11 OTU (with crew)
o 31 Jul 42 – Fg Off from Plt Off
o 10 Sep 43 – DFC awarded on 214 Sqn
o 1 Aug 43 – 1657 CU (as A/Flt Lt)
o 24 Nov 43 – Flt Lt
o 14 Jun 45 – MiD as A/Sqn Ldr
o Apr 46 Returned to NZ
John Syddall Williams – RNZAF404977
o Killed in Action – 25 May 1942 – 22OTU
o Final Rank – Sergeant
Robin William Morton – RNZAF411725
o 24 Nov 41 – Plt Off from Sgt
o Killed in Action – 3 July 1942 – 18 Sqn
o Final Rank – Pilot Officer
RC Spittal – RNZAF 404420 Philip Charles Spittal
o 24 Nov 41 – Plt Off from Sgt – observer
o Spring 42 – 11 OTU
o Jul 42 – 75 Sqn
o Killed in action – 26 July 1942
AJ McDonogh (RCAF) – R86834 Athol Ian McDonogh
o Service record shows at 5BGS on the above date
o 20 Apr 42 – 25 OTU
o 6 Aug 42 – 75 Sqn
o Killed in action – 21 Aug 1942
BS Sinclair – RNZAF411731 Bruce Stalley Sinclair
o ? Mar 41 – enlisted as U/T AO
o 24 Nov 41 – Plt Off from Sgt – observer
o 1 Oct 42 – Fg Off from Plt Off
o 24 Nov 43 – Flt Lt from Fg Off
o 10 Dec 42 – 42 Sqn
o 31 Mar 44 – ?217 Sqn
Kenneth Stuart Spencer – RNZAF41552
o 3 Mar 43 – 11OTU
o Killed in Action – 29 July 1942 – 1656CU
o Final Rank – Sergeant
GH Dunn – RNZAF 411790 Gordon Henry Dunn
o 1 Jul 43 – Plt off from Flt Sgt
o 1 Jan 44 – Fg Off from Plt Off
o 1 Jun 45 – Flt Lt from Fg Off
o 28 Mar 48 – Commission relinquished
ES Roberts – RNZAF411728 Eric Samuel Roberts
o 24 Nov 41 – Plt Off from Sgt
o 1 Oct 43 – Fg Off from Plt Off
o 24 Nov 43 – Flt Lt from Fg Off
o 42 – 44 – ?22, 42 and 217 Sqns
o B. 1916, d. 2006
E Garnett (?)(RAF),
Norman Lee Burton – RNZAF41531
o Missing in Action – 2 October 1943
o Final Rank – Flying Officer
LV Rosser – RNZAF411798 Leonard Victor Rosser
o 22 Dec 41 – Plt Off from Sgt
o 1 Apr 44 – Flt Lt from Fg Off
o ?108 Sqn
o B. 1920, d. 1994
Noble Andrew Gardiner – RNZAF41579
o Killed in Action – 28 July 1943
o Final Rank – Flying Officer
G Nimmo – RNZAF404931 George Nimmo
o 24 Nov 41 – Plt Off from Sgt
o 27 May 42 – 221 Sqn from 17 OUT
o 1 Sep 42 – 464 Sqn from 221 Sqn
o 10 Oct 42 – Fg Off from Plt Off
o 24 Nov 43 – Flt Lt from Fg Off
James Allan Logan – RNZAF404908
o Killed in Flying Accident – 10 November 1942
o Final Rank – Flying Officer
Ian Ignatius Friend – RNZAF404350
o Killed in Action – 9 November 1942
o Final Rank – Sergeant
Max Hilton Elliott.
o Killed in Action – 30 September 1942
o Final Rank – Sergeant (see above)
There is a confusion in the names on the photograph. The front row has 16 airmen but 17
names are shown. I contend that MA Elliott (with no.17 next to him) is M H Elliott.